Spring Mattress vs Foam Mattress | Guide 2022

If you are looking for a new mattress, you will see a number of different mattress types. The three main types are foam, springs, and hybrid, which is a combination of foam and springs. Whether you’re shopping at an online bed-in-a-box business or a physical store, all three of these types will be easy to find. The trick is to figure out what type of mattress you prefer.

When selecting a type of mattress, it all depends on your personal preferences. While some like the close-fitting feel of an all-foam model, others prefer a spring mattress because they want to feel like they’re sleeping on top of their bed rather than curling up. sink into it. It’s worth noting that most models include a 100-night sleep trial, meaning you can return it within that time frame if you find it not comfortable.

What is a spring mattress made of?

Spring mattresses get their name from their support layer made up of steel springs. These coils are not as dense as foam and as such can help promote airflow (a benefit for hot sleepers). In particular, the thickness of the springs of the bed determines the firmness of the mattress. With this in mind, there are different variations of coils on the market: Bonnell, bagged, staggered and continuous.

Hourglass-shaped, Bonnell springs were featured in the first commercial spring mattress. They are still used today and are cost effective to produce, which means spring mattresses that use Bonnell coils are generally less expensive.

Pocket coils are individually wrapped in fabric sleeves, allowing each coil to operate independently of each other. Although this reduces noise and motion transfer, models built with this system usually sell for a higher price.

Similar to pocket coils, offset coils are also more expensive to manufacture than Bonnell coils, but offer greater firmness. As for the structure, they are linked together by articulated wires to provide sleepers with different levels of support depending on their needs. For example, they flex under light pressure but give a stronger thrust when more weight is applied.

Continuous yarn bobbins use a single yarn formed into a series of loose loops, which are then connected by helical lacing. Thanks to their waterproof construction, they are both durable and stable. In addition, their production does not require much time and money, since their design is simple. In fact, these are the most affordable variants you can buy.

What is a foam mattress made of?

Standard memory foam mattresses are made of a polyurethane-based memory foam that conforms to the sleeper’s body, providing pressure point relief. Since foam retains heat, some memory foam models are infused with gel or copper, which can help keep sleepers cool. Gel-infused foam mattresses, for example, feature built-in gel beads to help redistribute heat better. Latex models use natural or synthetic latex foam. They tend to be denser and more durable than traditional foam beds.

The price of a foam mattress varies depending on the materials used. Polyurethane foam, sometimes called polyfoam, is relatively inexpensive, while memory foam, copper-infused foam, and gel-infused foam are more expensive. Likewise, latex, which is a premium material that lasts longer, is more expensive than polyurethane foam.

If you’re looking for a new mattress, there are budget foam beds. Considering our ranking of the best memory foam mattresses of 2022, the most affordable bed on the list costs $415. Plus, a handful of other foam mattresses in our review sell for less than $1,000.

Which is better: foam or spring mattress?

A memory foam mattress conforms to the contours of your body, which is important for side sleepers who need to sink deeper into a mattress so that their hips and shoulders align. Lighter sleepers generally prefer this type of mattress because the softness allows them to sink in and relieve pressure points. But memory foam has a reputation for retaining heat. If you tend to sleep hot, it’s worth considering a foam bed with cooling features added to the foam layers, such as gel or copper particles.

Spring mattresses, on the other hand, do not share this problem because their springs allow for greater air circulation. Plus, they’re generally firmer and more responsive, making them more suitable for those who need more support, especially stomach sleepers or heavier people.

Foam mattresses excel at motion isolation, a feature couples will appreciate. Instead of transferring motion, the foam absorbs it, preventing partners from disturbing each other’s sleep when tossing and turning. Since spring mattresses bounce, you’re more likely to hear and feel your partner’s movements.

When you first remove a foam mattress from its packaging, it is more prone to off-gassing, which is an initial chemical odor resulting from the release of volatile organic compounds (VOCs). Although unpleasant, the smell has no known long-term effects and usually dissipates within a few days. However, it’s a good idea to keep a window open when unpacking your bed to reduce the smell. You can also look for Global Organic Latex Standard (GOLS) certified latex which is designed to contain very low VOCs and any off-gassing should be non-toxic. As another option, if you can’t choose between foam and coils, a hybrid mattress combines both memory foam and coils, providing both support and rebound.

Are foam or spring mattresses better for back pain?

A study conducted by the National Center for Biotechnology Information found that medium-firm mattresses are best for people with back pain. Mattresses that are too firm don’t provide enough comfort for pressure points, while beds that are too soft lack the support needed for spinal alignment.

Of all the models in our ranking of the best mattresses for back pain, most of those at the top of our list are hybrid mattresses, which are constructed with both coils and memory foam. They are more responsive than traditional memory foam beds due to their coils, while still providing the body-contouring support and pressure relief that foam mattresses provide. Compared to spring models, hybrid beds feature more robust comfort layers.

Some mattresses on the market feature zoned support, which can provide targeted firmness to areas that bear more weight, such as the hips and lower back. For added comfort, some brands also sell mattress toppers for an additional charge, which can add softness to your existing mattress.

Choosing the right firmness depends on an individual’s body weight, sleeping position and personal preference. It’s important for back pain sufferers to keep in mind that most mattresses include a trial period which is usually 100 days, but can sometimes last up to a year. If the bed you purchased is not comfortable, you can return it within this period for a full refund.

How long do foam mattresses last compared to spring mattresses?

Foam mattresses typically last between six and seven years, while spring beds have a shorter expected lifespan (around five to six years). However, this depends on many factors, including the materials of the mattress. For example, high density polyfoam and latex are more durable than low density polyfoam, which wears out faster.

Weight and sleeping position have an impact on the longevity of a mattress. Couples put more stress on a bed than an individual sleeper. Additionally, heavier people may notice their bed sag prematurely, while side sleepers may find indentations in the areas where they rest their hips and shoulders. At a minimum, most mattress brands offer a limited warranty of at least 10 years, although there are brands that offer much longer periods. In most cases, however, this does not cover everyday wear and tear.

Learn more

Other ratings from 360 reviews

Why you can trust us: 312 mattresses searched

At US News & World Report, we rank the best hospitals, the best colleges, and the best cars to guide readers through some of life’s most complicated decisions. Our 360 Reviews team uses this same unbiased approach to evaluate the products you use every day. To compile our ranking of the best mattresses of 2022, our certified mattress and sleep science specialists studied over 312 mattresses and analyzed 20 reviews. Our 360 Reviews team does not take samples, giveaways, or loans of products or services we review. All product samples provided for review are given after review. Additionally, we maintain a separate sales team that has no influence over our methodology or recommendations. See more details on our 360 methodology for mattress evaluation.